Year Opponent Score Result Round
2012 Northern Illinois 51-68 L First
2011 Akron 65-76 L First
2010 Ball State 43-67 L First
2009 Ohio 57-68 L First
2008 Akron 84-54 W Quarterfinals
  Miami 60-65 L Semifinals
2007 Miami 74-58 W Quarterfinals
  Ball State 56-63 L Semifinals
2006 Toledo 59-64 (OT)
 L Quarterfinals
2005 Miami 71-74 L First
2004 Akron 83-67 W First
  Bowling Green 62-63 L Quarterfinals
2003 Akron 101-60 W First
  Kent State 87-72 W Quarterfinals
  Toledo 60-57 W Semifinals
  Ball State 81-76 W Championship
2002 Central Michigan 77-67 W First

Miami 70-77 L Quarterfinals
2001 Bowling Green 75-78 L First
2000 Bowling Green
 87-63 W Quarterfinals
  Toledo 55-64 L Semifinals
1999 Eastern Michigan 95-68 W Quarterfinals
  Kent State 50-60 L Semifinals
1996 Miami 76-79 L Quarterfinals
1995 Bowling Green 67-64 W Quarterfinals
  Toledo 73-82 L Semifinals
1994 Ohio 76-61 W Quarterfinals
  Toledo 68-69 L Semifinals
1993 Miami 67-71 L Quarterfinals
1990 Toledo 55-68 L Quarterfinals
1989 Ball State 59-81 L Quarterfinals
1988 Miami 66-63 W Quarterfinals
  Bowling Green 53-70 L Semifinals
1987 Central Michigan 70-82 L Quarterfinals
1986 Ohio 70-73 L Semifinals
1985 Miami 87-77 W Semifinals
  Central Michigan 73-63 W Championship
1982 Central Michigan 45-47 L First