Mid-American Conference Tournament
Year  Opponent Result Round Site
2011 Northern Illinois L, 0-1 Championship Akron, Ohio
  Akron T, 1-1 (won shootout, 4-3) Semifinals Akron, Ohio
2010 Akron L, 0-4 Championship Akron, Ohio
  Bowling Green W, 1-0 Semifinals Akron, Ohio
2009 Hartwick L, 2-3 Semifinals Akron, Ohio
2008 Hartwick L, 0-4 Quarterfinals Akron, Ohio
2007 Hartwick

T, 1-1 (lost shootout, 4-2)

 Quarterfinals  Oneonta, N.Y.
2006 Bowling Green L, 1-2 Quarterfinals  Kalamazoo, Mich.
2005 Akron L, 0-5 Semifinals Akron, Ohio
  Bowling Green W, 2-0 Quarterfinals  Kalamazoo, Mich.
2004 Akron L, 1-6 Championship Akron, Ohio
  Kentucky W, 1-0 Semifinals Kalamazoo, Mich.
  Marshall

T, 2-2 (won shootout)

 Quarterfinals  Kalamazoo, Mich.
2003 Bowling Green  W, 5-0 Championship Kalamazoo, Mich.
  Akron T, 0-0 (won shootout) Semifinals Bowling Green, Ohio
  Marshall W, 1-0 Quarterfinals  Bowling Green, Ohio
2002 Akron  L, 0-3 Quarterfinals  Huntington, Wva.
2001 Marshall  L, 1-3 Quarterfinals  Akron, Ohio
2000 Marshall  L, 1-2 (2OT) Quarterfinals  Buffalo, N.Y.
1999 Kentucky L, 0-3 Semifinals DeKalb, Ill.
  Akron W, 2-1 Quarterfinals  DeKalb, Ill.
1998 Akron L, 0-5 Quarterfinals  Lexington, Ky.
1997 Kentucky L, 1-2 Quarterfinals  Oxford, Ohio
1996 Kentucky L, 0-1 Quarterfinals  Bowling Green, Ohio
1995 Miami L, 1-3 Quarterfinals  Kalamazoo, Mich.
1994 Miami L, 2-6 Semifinals Akron, Ohio
  Central Michigan W, 2-0 Quarterfinals  Akron, Ohio
 
NCAA Tournament
2003 UW-Milwaukee L, 1-4 First Round Milwaukee, Wis.